ARTICLE TOOLS
Chattanooga: Roundabout way to ease congestion
Included in this article
The thought of driving in circles used to drive City Councilman Jack Benson crazy.
When news broke about roundabouts coming to the intersection of Gunbarrel and Standifer Gap roads, his phone rang off the hook from worried drivers.
“No one wanted roundabouts in our district,” Mr. Benson said. “There was too much trepidation and fear of the unknown.”
But Chattanooga Traffic Engineer John Van Winkle convinced Mr. Benson the roundabout was needed, and the city put it in last year. Now traffic in the area flows smoothly and public perception has changed, Mr. Benson said.
“I’ve had many (people) call me and tell me how wrong they once were,” Mr. Benson said.
City officials are considering building a ninth roundabout at the intersection of Shallowford and Jenkins roads, they said. The city’s Engineering Department is designing a roundabout for that location, but personnel did not return calls Friday seeking comment.
Construction on the roundabout should start in June or July, Mr. Van Winkle said. He could not give an estimated cost of the project but said roundabouts generally cost more upfront than putting in traffic lights. Afterward, though, the cost goes down, he said.
“You don’t have recurring costs of maintenance,” he said.
Lee Norris, deputy administrator of the city’s Public Works Department, said the roundabouts are “paying off.”
“People are shocked when they first come across a roundabout,” he said. “But people are a lot more receptive to it now.”
The first modern roundabout was placed in the city in 2001 on the Chattanooga side of the Bachman Tunnel leading to East Ridge, he said. The state put in two roundabouts below state Highway 153 two years ago at a cost of $6 million, officials said.
A roundabout at W and Mountain Creek roads cost substantially less at about $230,000, they said.
CITY ROUNDABOUTS
There are eight roundabouts in Chattanooga:
* Bachman Tunnel at Tennessee Highway 31
* Mountain Creek Road at W Road
* Elder Mountain Road at O’Grady Drive
* Igou Gap Road at Clearview Road
* Igou Gap Road at Gray Road
* Access Road at Highway 153
* Lake Resort Drive at Highway 153
* Gunbarrel Road at Standifer Gap Road
Source: Chattanooga government
Mr. Van Winkle said no studies have been conducted on whether traffic accidents have gone down at any of the intersections where roundabouts were built. High numbers of accidents at the locations were not the problem, though, he said.
“These were not really built for accident problems as much as congestion,” he said.
Mr. Van Winkle said he sees potential for roundabouts correcting some of the city’s most accident-laden intersections such as the entrance and exits from Hixson Pike to Highway 153. That interchange is consistently one of the most accident-prone in the city, he said, and he has sketched out a drawing of roundabouts that could be placed on each end of the bridge.
Share This...
These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.This document may not be reprinted without the express written permission of Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc.



Comments
I have lived near Shallowford and Jenkins road for 21 years and a roundabout will not work here. This intersection, unlike those on Igou Gap, have businesses and a church/school on each corner that causes a traffic jam each day from people stopping in the road to wait to turn into these areas. A roundabout is a 360 degree yeild sign with nothing to govern or stop the traffic; it will back up into the roundabout. What is and always has been needed at this intersection is a turning lane and a traffic light timed correctly. They might work well in some areas of town but it will be a nightmare at Shallowford and jenkins.
1 of 1 people found this comment useful.
Traffic circles [to use the proper American term instead of the trendy European one] have been with us since at least 1954 when I began driving on public roads in Los Angeles.
All in all, they are very effective in moving traffic -- provided everyone knows and abides by the rules of operation. All it takes is one incompetent driver to screw up the works -- and we seem to have more than a few on the roads here...
However, they are NOT the solution to all problems and circumstances, as pointed out above. A bit of study is required before putting the things in and bollixing up the works...would that Congress would take the hint.
0 of 0 people found this comment useful.
When I pick up my daughter from Lakeside, I have to go through the double "round about" off of Access Rd. I have had several near misses with people that fly through the intersections. These loop-ti-loops probably would work if everyone knew where they were going and how they work. Unfortunately, everyone doesn't know there way around these loops, and you have uncontrolled chaos. I know they cost more money, but give me the old red, yellow and green traffic light anyday. I think Mr. Van Winkle needs to get a second opinion on these things.
1 of 1 people found this comment useful.
Post a comment
Commenting requires registration.